I am looking at replacing my shafts in my fairway & hybrids to try to improve ball striking consistency, I was recommended either the Aldila Rogue Silver 70/Black Hybrid or Xcaliber Tour Fairway/Hybrid.

How much does shaft weight affect the feel, and if it should be lighter or heavier to improve how I hit these clubs?

I know it’s a testing/trial & error thing but unfortunately unlimited funds don’t allow me to chop & change between shafts so I’d like some general guidance on which way to go for the first time. I find that when I try to swing easier and slightly slower I am getting better results with my irons & driver.